Google Home和Amazon Echo都是功能强大的智能助手,具有许多相同的功能,但都不是适合每个人的。很难确定哪个智能助手最能满足您的需求,但了解您在两者之间做出的决定会有所帮助。
本指南将分解Google Home 与(Google Home vs) Amazon Echo的功能,以帮助您确定两者中哪一个是您家的正确选择。这两个平台都具有令人印象深刻的功能,其中一些功能相似,但其中许多是助手特有的。
美学的感染力(Aesthetic Appeal)
人们的主要决定点之一不是功能,而是系统安装在他们家中的外观。毕竟,如果您在每个房间都安装智能助手,您希望它们看起来不错并适合其他装饰。在这方面,两家公司都没有领先优势。
Amazon Echo的设计多年来一直在改进,第三代是许多智能扬声器的最新版本。这些具有圆角和覆盖外部的织物的时尚设计。尽管该设备最初只有三种颜色选项,但该数量已增加到六种选择。
另一方面,Google Home Mini自推出以来并没有太大的设计变化。它的外观与Amazon Echo Dot相似,顶部为圆形,外部覆盖有织物。(top and fabric)谷歌主页(Google Home),系统命名的主要助手,根本没有改变。唯一值得注意的变化是命名方案。新(New)设备称为Nest,而不是Google。
最终,设备的美学吸引力归结为个人喜好。
预算(Budget)
另一个主要因素是你愿意花多少钱。好消息是,几乎所有价位都有智能助手,但它们并非都是平等的。
你必须决定你想要什么类型的助手。你想要一些面向声音的东西,还是有显示器的东西?您是否需要一个适合房间而不引起注意的小助手,或者您正在寻找平衡?
Amazon Echo Dot和Nest Home Mini的售价都在 50 美元左右,而Amazon Echo 和 Google Home(Amazon Echo and Google Home)的零售价都接近 100 美元。Nest Home Hub是一款带显示屏的智能助手,售价 90 美元,亚马逊 Echo Show 5(Amazon Echo Show 5)也是如此。
两者的价格都具有竞争力,而且如此接近,以至于在这一类别中没有明显的赢家。
功能性(Functionality)
这些助手真正与众不同的地方在于它们的功能。有大量仅与Alexa兼容的(Alexa)亚马逊品牌(Amazon-branded)智能设备,以及仅与Google Assistant兼容的同等数量的谷歌品牌设备。
这些品牌限制超出了第一方设备。好消息是,几乎所有支持Siri的设备都可以支持Amazon Echo、Google Assistant或两者。
亚马逊的Alexa是一个功能强大的系统,拥有超过 100,000 个“技能(Skills)”,用户可以随意启用或禁用类似应用程序的功能。这些技能使Alexa能够超越她的预编程功能。最重要的是,几乎任何人都可以编写新的Alexa 技能(Alexa skill)以满足特定需求。
虽然Google Assistant 没有(Google Assistant doesn)易于使用的技能系统(Skill system),但这并不意味着它不强大。Google Assistant能够通过Google Actions做很多事情。Google Actions 系统(Google Actions system)是Alexa Skills的解决方案,但它不如其对应系统强大、扩展或用户友好。
谷歌(Google)有一些Alexa没有的附加功能,特别是在硬件方面(hardware front)。例如,Nest Home Hub Max 内置了Nest摄像(Nest Home Hub Max)头(Nest Camera built-in)。这意味着您的智能显示器可以兼作家庭安全摄像头(home security camera)。
Google Assistant还支持Google Music 和 YouTube(Google Music and YouTube)。另一方面,Alexa支持Amazon Music 和 Prime Music(Amazon Music and Prime Music)。其他流媒体服务(如Spotify)可以通过任一平台进行控制。
Alexa在(Alexa)软件方面(software front)往往更强大(尽管并非在所有情况下都是如此),而Google Home往往拥有更强大的硬件。
Google Home 与 Amazon Echo(Google Home Vs Amazon Echo)
在两者之间做出决定归结为几个简单的问题:您还有哪些其他设备?如果您的智能设备主要与Google Home配合使用,那么这就是您要选择的平台。如果它们是亚马逊特定的,请选择Alexa。
哪些功能对您来说最重要?如果您的整个音乐库(music library)都在Amazon上,那么Alexa是更好的选择。如果您倾向于Google 音乐(Google Music),请选择Google Home。Alexa Skills使其成为一种流行的选择,但如果您不需要自定义技能,任何一个都可以工作 - 功能上的差异还没有那么大,以至于它产生了巨大的差异。
你觉得哪一个更好看?由于审美吸引力确实在选择智能助手方面发挥了重要作用,因此请选择您最喜欢的那个。
最后,你的预算是多少?这两款设备的价格非常接近,以至于预算几乎不是决定因素。两个智能助手平台的微型、标准和显示版本的价格相似。只有当您达到两者中的高端时,价格才会有所不同,即便如此,差别也不大。
如果您需要智能助手,Amazon Echo 和 Google Home(Amazon Echo and Google Home)都是不错的选择。花点时间在两者之间做出决定。如果您发现即使是低端机型也超出了您的预算,请等待促销或特价促销。他们经常来,是亲自尝试助手的好方法。
你更喜欢 Google Home 还是 Amazon Echo?请在下面的评论中告诉我们。(Do you prefer Google Home or Amazon Echo? Let us know in the comments below.)
Google Home Vs Amazon Echo: Which Is The One For You?
Both the Google Home and the Amazon Echo are powerful smart aѕsistants with many of the same functіons, but neither one is the right fit for each persоn. It can be hard to narrow down which smart assistant will ѕerνe yoυr needs best, but it helps to know what you’re deciding between.
This guide will break down the functionality of Google Home vs Amazon Echo to help you decide which of the two is the right choice for your home. Both platforms have impressive functions, some of which are similar, but many of which are specific to the assistant.
Aesthetic Appeal
One of the major deciding points for people isn’t the functionality, but how good a system will look installed in their home. After all, if you install smart assistants in every room, you want them to look good and fit with the rest of the decor. On that front, neither company has a lead.
The design of the Amazon Echo has improved throughout the years, with the third generation being the most recent iteration for many of the smart speakers. These have a sleek design with rounded corners and fabric covering the exterior. Although the device originally only had three color options, that number has increased to six choices.
On the other hand, the Google Home Mini has not changed its design much since its launch. It has a similar look to the Amazon Echo Dot, with a rounded top and fabric covering the exterior. The Google Home, the primary assistant for which the system is named, has not changed at all. The only noteworthy change is in the naming scheme. New devices are called Nest, not Google.
Ultimately, the aesthetic appeal of the devices comes down to personal preference.
Budget
Another major factor is how much you are willing to spend. The good news is that there are smart assistants available at virtually all price points, but they are not all created equal.
You have to decide what type of assistant you want. Do you want something geared towards sound, or something with a display? Do you need a small assistant that fits in a room without drawing attention, or are you looking for a balance?
The Amazon Echo Dot and the Nest Home Mini are both roughly $50, while the Amazon Echo and Google Home both retail for close to $100. The Nest Home Hub, the smart assistant with a display, goes for $90, as does the Amazon Echo Show 5.
The prices for both are competitive, and so close that there is no clear winner in this category.
Functionality
The area where these assistants really set themselves apart from one another is in their functionality. There are a huge number of Amazon-branded smart devices that are only compatible with Alexa, and an equal number of Google-branded devices that work only with Google Assistant.
These brand limitations extend beyond first-party devices. The good news is that almost any device that works with Siri will also work with either Amazon Echo, Google Assistant, or both.
Amazon’s Alexa is a powerful system with more than 100,000 “Skills,” app-like functions that users can enable or disable at will. These skills enable Alexa to go far beyond her pre-programmed functionality. Best of all, nearly anyone can program a new Alexa skill to meet a specific need.
While Google Assistant doesn’t have an easy to use Skill system, that doesn’t mean it isn’t powerful. Google Assistant is capable of doing quite a bit through Google Actions. The Google Actions system is the answer to Alexa Skills, but it isn’t as robust, expansive, or user-friendly as its counterpart.
Google has a few additional features that Alexa does not, particularly on the hardware front. The Nest Home Hub Max, for example, has a Nest Camera built-in. This means your smart display can double as a home security camera.
Google Assistant also supports Google Music and YouTube. On the other hand, Alexa supports Amazon Music and Prime Music. Other streaming services like Spotify can be controlled through either platform.
Alexa tends to be more powerful on the software front (although this isn’t true in every case), while Google Home tends to have the stronger hardware.
Google Home Vs Amazon Echo
Deciding between the two boils down to a few simple questions: what other devices do you have? If your smart devices work mostly with Google Home, then that’s the platform you want to choose. If they are Amazon-specific, choose Alexa instead.
What functions are most important to you? If your entire music library is on Amazon, then Alexa is the better option. If you lean towards Google Music, then opt for Google Home. The Alexa Skills make it a popular choice, but if you don’t need custom skills, either one will work—the differences in functionality are not yet so drastic that it makes a huge difference.
Which one looks better to you? Since aesthetic appeal does play a large role in choosing a smart assistant, pick the one you prefer most.
Finally, what is your budget? The two devices are so close in price that budget is hardly a deciding factor. The miniature, standard, and display versions of both smart assistant platforms are similarly priced. It is only when you reach the high-end of the two that prices vary, and even then it isn’t by much.
If you need a smart assistant, both Amazon Echo and Google Home are great choices. Take the time to decide between the two. If you find that even the low-end models are outside your budget, wait for a sale or special promotion. They come often and are a great way to try the assistants out for yourself.
Do you prefer Google Home or Amazon Echo? Let us know in the comments below.